Overall, positive. The fabric is very nice quality. They provide privacy, but still let in a pleasant amount of light. Problem was that when I put them on the rod, the lining hung below the curtain fabric. Not sure if this was the case when I opened the package as I did not notice it. May have occurred when I washed them, but I washed them in cold water, quick wash, light soil and put them in the dryer on delicate cycle briefly - the curtains were not even entirely dry when I removed them from the dryer. I would have given the item five stars if the lining did not hang below the curtains. Fortunately, they are in my exercise room and not a main room in the house.